Electronic Music mailing list archives

Previous Message: Re: System Restore...
Next Message: Re: need advice re: Windows registry cleaners (majorly

From: Mark Knecht ()
Date: May 2, 2008
Subject: Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code
On Fri, May 2, 2008 at 3:52 PM, Esben Stien  wrote:
> "Mark Knecht"  writes:
>
>
> > The GPL doesn't protect my 'interests' as a tester/contributor
>  > bucause my name isn't listed in the code header.
>
>  This is wrong. If you got contributions to the code base you are also
>  a copyright holder. The law protects you here. This means they cannot
>  change the license of the particular files you contributed to, without
>  your consent or without removing your contributions. This is protected
>  by law.
>

Well, the problem is that as a tester/contributor my contributions to
the project is direct but to the code is indirect. I never wrote a
line of code in LS and don't want anyone to think I did. However I
would strongly suggest that LS wouldn't have made nearly the progress
is did make in the time it did without all the work I did looking for
inconsistencies in how GigaStudio handled a specific gig file vs how
LS did. My contribution was to push them to make a product that
professional users of GSt would consider using. However, I wrote no
code and my name appears nowhere in any file, as is probably
appropriate.
>
>  > I'm not personally sure what the FSF could really do for us on this
>  > subject but I'd be interested in knowing.
>
>  It's not up to the FSF, as long as they don't hold the copyright to
>  the work.
>
>
>  -- [EMAIL REMOVED]     s      a
>          http://www. s     t    n m
>           irc://irc.  b  -  i  .   e/%23contact [EMAIL REMOVED]  e     e [EMAIL REMOVED]   n     n
>  _______________________________________________
>
>
> Linux-audio-user mailing list [EMAIL REMOVED] >  http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user
>
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list [EMAIL REMOVED] http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

+ Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code bradley newton haug (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code drew Roberts (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Dave Phillips (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Rob (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code drew Roberts (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Paul Coccoli (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Jack O'Quin (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Arthur (05/01/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Ken Restivo (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Esben Stien (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Esben Stien (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Mark Knecht (05/02/08)
+---Re: Pre-License change LinuxSampler code Arda Eden (05/12/08)

Previous Message: Re: System Restore...
Next Message: Re: need advice re: Windows registry cleaners (majorly